News

Bosworth - Battlefield Trust Letter to Hinckley and Bosworth Borough Council Planning Committee Members
21 September 2018
On 19 September, the Battlefields Trust sent the following letter to Hinckley and Bosworth Borough Council Planning Committee members explaining why the Trust disagrees with the planning advice the Committee has received in respect of the proposed autonomous vehicle planning application for Bosworth battlefield and why battolefields are important heritage assets.
The Planning Committee meets on 25 September to determine the outcome of the planning application. The Trust has been denied an opportunity to speak at the meeting by the Council, but is working with the Richard III on a joint statement of opposition. A further update will be provided once the planning decision has been taken.
BEGINS
Dear Hinckley and Bosworth Borough Council Planning Committee member,
In advance of the site visit in connection with planning application 18/00425/FUL, which affects the Bosworth battlefield, I am writing to you on behalf of the Battlefields Trust to set out the Trust’s position on the planning advice that you have received from Historic England and Council officials and to explain why battlefields are important heritage assets.
I apologise for the length of this email, but the Battlefields Trust judges it is important that you understand in summary:
- That in the Trust’s view Historic England’s assessment is at odds with current government guidance on defining substantial harm to heritage assets and it has underplayed the significance of the threat to the battlefield at Bosworth
- That, also in the Trust’s view, the implications of the National Planning Policy Framework and Policy DM12 in the Hinckley and Bosworth Borough Council Local Plan have not been fully articulated by officers.
Planning Advice Aspects
The planning issues I would like to address are those raised by the original planning report on the MIRA application produced by Hinckley and Bosworth Borough Council planning officers and within Historic England's letter to the planning officer of 5 September 2018.
Turning to the latter first. The Historic England Inspector identifies the key parts of the battlefield as being the royalist encampment, Henry's approach and the battle itself. The Inspectors view is that these key areas are unaffected by the development. In respect of the royalist camp this is correct, but for the approach of Henry's army the information provided to the planning committee by the Battlefields Trust demonstrates that this is incorrect. For the battle, it is clearly not the case, as archaeology relating to the fighting has been found on the proposed development site by the applicant's pre-development archaeological investigations; the location of an artillery round-shot fired during the battle being physical evidence of the location of that battle. Dr Foard addresses this issue further in his email.
It is important that Historic England has identified these locations as key parts of the battlefield as the government's own planning guidance sets out the criteria for determining substantial harm to heritage assets (see https://www.gov.uk/guidance/conserving-and-enhancing-the-historic-environment). The relevant paragraph in this guidance says:
Whether a proposal causes substantial harm will be a judgment for the decision taker, having regard to the circumstances of the case and the policy in the National Planning Policy Framework. In general terms, substantial harm is a high test, so it may not arise in many cases. For example, in determining whether works to a listed building constitute substantial harm, an important consideration would be whether the adverse impact seriously affects a key element of its special architectural or historic interest. It is the degree of harm to the asset’s significance rather than the scale of the development that is to be assessed. The harm may arise from works to the asset or from development within its setting (my emphasis)
On this basis substantial harm considerations need to relate to key elements of historic interest in respect of the heritage asset (which Historic England has now helpfully identified for Bosworth battlefield) and it is the degree of harm to the asset rather than the scale of development that matters; whether the development harms 0.5 percent or 20 percent of the heritage asset is not necessarily relevant.
Given this, the fact that some of the key elements can objectively be shown to be adversely affected by the proposed development and that the current heritage assessment guidance is clear that it is not the scale of the development but the harm that arises to these key elements that determines whether harm is substantial, then the Trust argues that this high threshold has been reached.
The Battlefields Trust therefore judges that Historic England’s assessment does not accurately reflect the full extent of the threat to the battlefield. This is unfortunate, but understandable. Since the decision to abolish its Battlefield Panel in 2015, Historic England has been without specialist battlefield advice and has had to rely on its more generalist local inspectors. These have a good expert understanding of heritage issues in the round, but no specific battlefield expertise.
The issue of harm, including substantial harm, is of particular importance. The Battlefields Trust has noted the advice report on application 18/00425/FUL prepared by the Borough Council's planning officers. It was surprised that National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) paragraph 194 did not seem to have been referenced and that the full implications of para 193 was not drawn out in this document. In light of this, it is worth setting out para 193 and para 194 of the NPPF in full:
193. When considering the impact of a proposed development on the significance of a designated heritage asset, great weight should be given to the asset’s conservation (and the more important the asset, the greater the weight should be). This is irrespective of whether any potential harm amounts to substantial harm, total loss or less than substantial harm to its significance [my emphasis]
194. Any harm to, or loss of, the significance of a designated heritage asset (from its alteration or destruction, or from development within its setting), should require clear and convincing justification. Substantial harm to or loss of:
a) grade II listed buildings, or grade II registered parks or gardens, should be exceptional;
b) assets of the highest significance, notably scheduled monuments, protected wreck sites, registered battlefields, grade I and II* listed buildings, grade I and II* registered parks and gardens, and World Heritage Sites, should be wholly exceptional [my emphasis].
All parties agree that Bosworth battlefield is a heritage asset of international importance. NPPF para 193 therefore imposes a duty on the planning committee to attach great weight to its conservation. All parties are also agreed that the proposed development will cause harm to the battlefield. On the basis of NPPF para 194 the planning committee is required to decide whether there is clear and convincing justification for agreeing the application. If not, the application should be rejected.
Separately policy DM12 of the Hinckley and Bosworth Borough Council Local Plan is stronger than the NPPF when it says ‘Proposals which adversely affect the Bosworth Battlefield or its setting should be wholly exceptional and accompanied by clear and convincing justification’. Adverse affect – something bad happening - is at a level below substantial harm, but the plan suggests even at this level, any development should be wholly exceptional.
Notwithstanding this, if the planning committee accepts the Battlefields Trust argument that substantial harm would now be caused, based on Historic England's declaration of the key elements of the battlefield in its 5 September letter and the criteria in current government ‘substantial harm’ guidance, then such development should, in any case, be wholly exceptional and the planning application rejected unless such exceptional circumstances can be evidenced. The Trust has seen no such evidence to date.
The Importance of Battlefields as Heritage Assets
People visit battlefields for a variety of reasons. Some are military historians who want to understand the lie of the land and compare the accounts of the battle to the terrain which survive from the period. Seeing the ground at first hand and identifying important features can add considerable understanding to the way a battle was fought. Others visit because there is a strong sense of place where momentous events occurred which provides an opportunity for them to walk in the footsteps of history. Battlefields are also a place of contemplation for some, where they can remember the brutal events that occurred and show their respect for those who fell in battle.
Battlefields harbour the archaeology of conflict. This is a fragile and limited resource, deposited in a matter of hours and existing only in the plough soil. Recovering and recording such archaeology systematically (often only through sampling due to the scale of battlefields), augments the written accounts, historic landscape and field walking to provide a rich additional resource for understanding how the battle was fought.
Bosworth is exceptional in this respect, now having given-up around 40 late medieval artillery round shots, more than the rest of Europe put together. The analysis of these finds has provided new insight, not only into how the battle at Bosworth was fought, but also how early firepower developed. These finds and their analysis have been recognised as being of international importance.
As the Hinckley and Bosworth Local Plan says ‘the Battle of Bosworth ranks with Hastings as one of the most decisive battles in British history and is considered of outstanding national and international importance’. It is where the Plantagenet dynasty ended and the Tudor one began. It ended the medieval period and heralded the modern. It is one of the most important battlefields in England and its preservation should be of high priority for everyone.
ENDS
Online lectures
1 December 2020
Read More
New planning proposals to threaten battlefields?
20 October 2020
Read More
Bosworth Book Offer
6 October 2020
Read More
Online lectures
29 August 2020
Read More
Possible Threat to Edgcote Battlefield
7 August 2020
Read More
Online Lectures
6 August 2020
Read More
Summer Reading
14 July 2020
Read More
Battlefields Trust You Tube
4 June 2020
Read More
Historical Association
29 April 2020
Read More
New video on the Battle of Langport
3 April 2020
Read More
Battlefields Trust Annual General Meeting
24 March 2020
Read More
Cancellation of 2020 Conference
24 March 2020
Read More
New video on the Battle of Cheriton
23 March 2020
Read More
Help preserve access to battlefields
26 February 2020
Read More
Trust Battlefields Panel
27 January 2020
Read More
New Trust film on the Battle of Carham
8 January 2020
Read More
2020 Conference and AGM
22 September 2019
Read More
Bosworth battlefield gov.uk petition
26 June 2019
Read More
Naseby Battlefield Project wins new funding
25 May 2019
Read More
Battle of Barnet 1471 - new video launched by the Barnet Battlefield Project
29 March 2019
Read More
Fornham St Genevieve 1173 - planning application may impact Suffolk's most important battlefield
24 March 2019
Read More
Battlefields Trust 2019 AGM and Conference
22 February 2019
Read More
Reported new threat to Barnet battlefield
16 January 2019
Read More
Bosworth - Battlefield Trust Letter to Hinckley and Bosworth Borough Council Planning Committee Members
21 September 2018
Read More
Threat to Bosworth: update
3 September 2018
Read More
Threat to the Registered Battlefield of Bosworth
24 August 2018
Read More
Prayer Book Rebellion archaeological resource report published following a Freedom of Information request
6 July 2018
Read More
New Yorkshire Region Chair
1 January 2018
Read More
Battlefields Trust e-Journal published
14 December 2017
Read More
Historic England Acknowledges Battlefields Trust Support on Battlefields At Risk
28 October 2017
Read More
Robert Hardy CBE, 1925-2017
11 August 2017
Read More
Nantwich (1644) Battlefield Under Threat
3 July 2017
Read More
Threat to Winwick (1648) Battlefield
3 July 2017
Read More
Historic England Complete the Review of Towton (1461) Battlefield Registration
8 June 2017
Read More
New Battlefields Trust Education Resources
16 May 2017
Read More
Battle of Barnet Project Update
22 April 2017
Read More
Development Threat to Babylon Hill Battlefield
17 April 2017
Read More
Chalgrove Battlefield Update
17 April 2017
Read More
Newbury II Added to the Battlefields Trust Resource Centre
18 February 2017
Read More
Chalgrove Airfield Development
23 January 2017
Read More
Battlefields poetry book available for purchase online
2 November 2016
Read More
Battlefields Trust AGM and Conference 2017
10 October 2016
Read More
Trust publishes battlefield poetry book
4 October 2016
Read More
Tewkesbury Battlefield Society Campaign to Buy Battlefield
2 September 2016
Read More
Princeton 1777 Battlefield Under Threat
1 September 2016
Read More
New battle of Langport trail
3 August 2016
Read More
Chalgrove Battlefield Under Threat
29 July 2016
Read More
Five Minute Battlefields - Langport
2 April 2016
Read More
Five Minute Battlefields - Cheriton
27 March 2016
Read More
Battlefields and the Teaching of History
28 February 2016
Read More
2016 Annual Conference and AGM
14 February 2016
Read More
The Civil War on Teeside
30 November 2015
Read More
Burglary of Medals at Talana Museum
13 October 2015
Read More
Please help us oppose threat to Northampton Battlefield
19 August 2015
Read More
Battlefields Trust Chair Stands Down
9 June 2015
Read More
Simon de Montfort 2014 Newsletter
25 May 2015
Read More
New Articles
25 May 2015
Read More
2015 AGM and Conference Documents
22 April 2015
Read More
Simon de Montfort 2014 Newsletter
8 April 2015
Read More
Northampton Battlefield Update
26 February 2015
Read More
Simon de Montfort 2014 Newsletter
13 February 2015
Read More
Oldest surviving Cannonball in England helps confirm the site of the 1460 Battle of Northampton
12 February 2015
Read More
Threat to Northampton Battlefield
23 January 2015
Read More
Planning application at Norton St Philip rejected
23 January 2015
Read More
Simon de Montfort 2014 Newsletter
12 January 2015
Read More
Member's Benefits Updated
6 January 2015
Read More
Battlefields Trust Annual Conference and AGM
6 January 2015
Read More
New Articles
30 December 2014
Read More
Battle of Tewkesbury - Arrivall Videos
30 December 2014
Read More
Simon de Montfort 2014 Newsletter
8 December 2014
Read More
Battlefields Trust Magazine
3 November 2014
Read More
Simon de Montfort 2014 Newsletter
2 November 2014
Read More
Battle of Lostwithiel 1644
31 October 2014
Read More
Nibley Green (1470) Update
17 October 2014
Read More
Threat to the Battlefield of Towton (1461)
22 September 2014
Read More
Nibley Green (1470) Update
20 September 2014
Read More
Simon de Montfort 2014 Newsletter
12 September 2014
Read More
Finding Fulford 1066
4 September 2014
Read More
Update on Prestonpans (1745) Threat
3 September 2014
Read More
Simon de Montfort 2014 Newsletter
25 August 2014
Read More
Trip to Normandy 2015
28 July 2014
Read More
Simon de Montfort 2014 Newsletter
22 July 2014
Read More
Nibley Green (1470) Battlefield Under Threat
28 June 2014
Read More
Winceby (1643) Battlefield Solar Array Decision
28 June 2014
Read More
Subscriptions: New rates from October
18 May 2014
Read More
Development Threat to Winceby Battlefield
13 May 2014
Read More
Simon de Montfort 2014 Newsletter
9 May 2014
Read More
The Gastons - Battle of Tewkesbury
9 May 2014
Read More
North East and Borders Regional News
29 April 2014
Read More
Battle of Bannockburn Visitor Centre
14 April 2014
Read More
Simon de Montfort 2014 Newsletter
24 March 2014
Read More
2014 Conference Programme
18 March 2014
Read More
Culloden Battlefield - Public Demonstrations
23 February 2014
Read More
Heritage Open Days
23 February 2014
Read More
Simon de Montfort 2014 Newsletter
17 February 2014
Read More
Battlefield Trust Journal
7 February 2014
Read More
Proposed housing development at Culloden
29 January 2014
Read More
Battlefields Trust 2014 Conference Booking Form
29 January 2014
Read More
New Articles
24 January 2014
Read More
Simon de Montfort 2014 Newsletter
24 January 2014
Read More
Opportunity to buy part of the battlefield of Tewkesbury
12 January 2014
Read More
Threat to Towton Battlefield
5 January 2014
Read More
Lunchtime talks at the Tower of London
18 December 2013
Read More
Wessex Region Newsletter
12 December 2013
Read More
The Civil War in the North East
7 December 2013
Read More
Sedgemoor wind turbine application withdrawn
28 November 2013
Read More
North East and Scottish Borders Newsletter
18 November 2013
Read More
Threat to setting of Battlefield of Sedgemoor
25 October 2013
Read More
Historical fiction talk rescheduled
21 October 2013
Read More
Members Articles
20 October 2013
Read More
Simon de Montfort 2014 Newsletter
20 October 2013
Read More
English Heritage register battlefield of Edgcote
7 October 2013
Read More
Threat to Langport (1645)
23 August 2013
Read More
Threat to Bramham Moor (1408) Battlefield
22 August 2013
Read More
Threat to Bothwell Bridge (1679) Battlefield
22 August 2013
Read More
Simon de Montfort 2014 Newsletter
15 August 2013
Read More
Leading Battlefield Walks
31 July 2013
Read More
Battlefields/Projects Update June 2013
2 July 2013
Read More
Simon de Montfort 2014 Newsletter
1 July 2013
Read More
York Council gives go-ahead for homes to be built on most likely site of the Battle of Fulford
26 April 2013
Read More
New Wind Turbine Threat to the Naseby Battlefield
10 April 2013
Read More
Bicentennial of the War of 1812
21 March 2013
Read More
The First Blitz Project
6 March 2013
Read More
News from Tewkesbury
5 March 2013
Read More
News from Northampton
9 February 2013
Read More
Richard III - What next?
6 February 2013
Read More
Battle of Hastings
14 January 2013
Read More
Battlefields Trust Magazine
20 December 2012
Read More
Battlefields Trust Job Adverts
25 November 2012
Read More
The threat to Towton battlefield
21 November 2012
Read More
Battlefields Trust on threat to Towton battlefield
16 November 2012
Read More
Battlefields Trust on threat to Northampton battlefield - Delapre Golf Complex Planning Application
14 November 2012
Read More
Civil War Grave Found in Northamptonshire Village
4 November 2012
Read More
Battle of Barnet 1471 Article
4 November 2012
Read More
English Heritage on the threat to Northampton Battlefield
16 October 2012
Read More
Battlefields Trust on threat to Northampton battlefield
16 October 2012
Read More
Report of the Finding of Richard III’s Grave
11 October 2012
Read More
Magazine Back issues
5 September 2012
Read More
London Lunchtime talks programme, Autumn 2012
4 September 2012
Read More
Expansion of Flodden 1513 Ecomuseum
1 May 2012
Read More
New lunchtime lecture series
13 April 2012
Read More
Heritage Tourism and the 2012 Olympics
2 April 2012
Read More
HS2 in 1862
17 January 2012
Read More
HS2 and the battlefield of Edgcote
13 January 2012
Read More
Statement on metal detecting
9 January 2012
Read More
Finding Bosworth
4 November 2009
Read More